Advertisement
A €2.2 billion pension fund's reckless real estate investments have triggered a cascade of corporate insolvencies, criminal investigations, and looming pension cuts for 10,000 German professionals. The financial distress at the Versorgungswerk der Zahnärztekammer Berlin reveals how amateur investment management can devastate institutional portfolios—and the companies that depend on them.
The market impact became visible in August when multiple Engel & Völkers licensees filed for insolvency after the Berlin Dental Association Pension Fund (VZB) suddenly stopped payments on agreed financing. EV Digital Invest, a crowd investing platform, collapsed first when a promised multimillion-euro loan was withdrawn. Two more Hamburg-based companies followed: EV Work Edition, operating co-working spaces, and EV Venture Management, supporting real estate startups.
"The decision not to pay loans to Engel & Völkers Venture Management and EV Work Edition is of a legal and economic nature," VZB told Immobilien Zeitung. But the damage was already spreading through Germany's real estate ecosystem, with eight companies belonging to Magna Real Estate, which is 60% owned by VZB, entering preliminary insolvency proceedings by late August.
The fund's investment strategy had veered far from conservative pension management. Under the leadership of former finance committee chairman Dr. Ingo R., VZB accumulated a portfolio of luxury hotels, startups, and speculative real estate ventures that regulatory guidelines should have prevented.
The scale of losses is staggering. A luxury hotel in Ibiza was devalued by €64.7 million within a year—from €138 million to €78 million. Three hotels held in a Luxembourg fund saw their combined book value shrink from €294.1 million to €205.3 million. A US plastic recycling startup, Rplanet Earth, consumed over €130 million—more than 5% of the fund's total capital investments.
Berlin prosecutors opened a criminal investigation in July focusing on Dr. Ingo R. (German media convention prevents full identification of accused individuals), the fund's former finance committee chairman, for alleged self-dealing. Among the accusations: purchasing a €1 million Magna Pershing 5X yacht and leasing it to the luxury resort '7 Pines' in Ibiza for €10,000 monthly—a resort in which he held a partnership stake.
Three independent law firms commissioned to review the fund's operations found "significant breaches of duty, violations of legal and internal investment guidelines, and failures in control mechanisms." The entire administrative committee has been replaced, with new chairman Thomas Schieritz warning members to expect "significant cuts in pension entitlements and increases in contributions."
One VZB administrative committee member estimates VZB's losses for 2023 alone at €84 million. The fund had opportunities to recover, according to Gerhard Gneist, member of VZB's representative assembly and chair of the Initiative of Independent Dentists Berlin. "In the first half of 2025, VZB had the opportunity to sell a business with a large property for a 'three-digit million' sum, which would have significantly strengthened the fund's financial position," Gneist explains. "However, the management committee did not open negotiations and the offer was withdrawn."
The VZB crisis demonstrates how pension fund mismanagement creates broader market instability. Engel & Völkers, despite emphasizing these were independent licensees, faces reputational damage and is considering legal action. The company offered multiple solutions to prevent insolvencies, including additional funding and subordination agreements, but VZB rejected all proposals.
"We must conclude that the VZB is clearly willing to accept the insolvency of investments, damage to its reputation and image, and further economic losses," Engel & Völkers stated. The insolvencies affect not only the companies involved but their tenants, investors, and business partners across Germany's real estate sector.
Provisional insolvency administrator Sven Hentschel, appointed by Hamburg Local Court, emphasizes business continuity: "I am currently working with the parties involved to gain an overview of the overall situation with the aim of ensuring the long-term survival of both companies." But the broader damage to market confidence may prove lasting.
The VZB debacle exposes fundamental weaknesses in Germany's professional pension system. Unlike statutory pensions, Versorgungswerke benefits depend directly on investment performance with no government safety net. Members bear full investment risk—a reality VZB members had already experienced in 2003 when pension entitlements were cut 16%.
The fund's investment committee consisted of practicing dentists rather than financial professionals, making complex real estate and private equity investments without appropriate expertise or oversight. Despite managing billions in member assets, regulatory supervision proved inadequate to prevent obvious conflicts of interest and speculative investments.
For institutional real estate investors, the VZB crisis offers crucial lessons about governance, risk management, and the dangers of abandoning fiduciary responsibility for speculative returns. The pension fund's attempt to boost performance through alternative investments—from luxury hotels to plastic recycling startups—demonstrates how quickly institutional capital can be destroyed when professional investment management is abandoned.
The ongoing criminal investigation and member lawsuits will likely continue for years, but the market disruption has already demonstrated how pension fund distress can cascade through real estate investment chains. For institutional investors, the VZB case highlights the interconnected nature of Germany's alternative investment ecosystem—where a single fund's problems can trigger insolvencies across multiple property ventures and threaten broader market confidence.
Get access to selected articles
